Skip to content
ARTUR NEUMANN

Get Newsletter Subscribers from Instagram Comments

By . Published November 18, 2026, updated November 18, 2026. 5 min read.

Turn Instagram comments into newsletter subscribers. My workflow connects a short video, a keyword, a message and a free book, followed by useful emails.

A comment on your video is a great starting point. Someone has shown interest in your topic. Nothing else has happened yet. You don’t know their name or email address.

I described in the article From Video to Email Contact how to get comments like these with a simple video. Here, I’ll cover what comes next. I’ll show you how to convert comments into newsletter subscribers, and how to create a newsletter from your videos that sparks new conversations every day.

From Comment to Sign-Up

The process has four steps:

  1. Your video begins with an engaging introduction that piques curiosity, followed by the main content. At the end, you say: “Comment with this word, and I’ll send you my book.”
  2. You publicly respond to each comment: “I’ve just sent you a private message.”
  3. In the private message, you might say: “I saw you’re interested in my stock market book. You can download it for free here.”
  4. The link leads to a page where the viewer enters their email address and receives the book after clicking “Free Download.”

That’s all it takes. The article Book as a Lead Magnet explains what to include in such a book and how long it should be.

Automate Your Messages

Nobody wants to manually reach out to 60 people every day. That’s why I’ve automated this process. You can do this with tools like ManyChat or with your own automation system. I’ve detailed the tools I use in the article AI Tools for Freelancers.

With automation, you can refine the process. Instead of immediately sending the link, you first ask for their email address. For example: “Great. What email address should I send the book to?” People will type their address directly into the chat.

In my system, the address is automatically added to my customer database. I built that connection between Instagram and my system myself. Then, I can immediately offer the next step in the same chat. This approach results in a very high conversion rate from comment to contact. As with any sign-up, the new subscriber confirms their address through a double opt-in.

The First Email Starts a Conversation

After signing up, the new subscriber receives a link to the book via email. The next morning, you send them a second email. In that email, you ask a question with a time-related element. For example: “You requested a book yesterday. Are you planning to invest in stocks this month?”

Adjust the question to fit your topic. If your book is about writing, you might ask: “Do you plan to write a book this month?” If you’re a dentist, you could ask: “Are you currently experiencing any dental issues?” These are deliberately specific examples. Phrase your question in your own words and with a more gentle approach.

This allows you to connect with people when they’re most receptive. You’re not pushing anyone; you’re gently guiding them into a conversation.

Those who respond are genuinely interested. Those who don’t are not quite ready yet. That’s perfectly fine. You have their email address and can continue to communicate with them.

One Video a Day Leads to a Newsletter a Day

Once you have those addresses, a daily newsletter becomes worthwhile. This requires discipline to create content every day. The best approach is a short video each day. If you can’t manage that, try every other day or once a week.

You don’t have to double your effort. Each video can become a newsletter. Here’s how it works:

  1. You record a video in the morning, or record seven videos once a week.
  2. You use AI to transcribe the video.
  3. The transcript is then used to create the text for your newsletter.
  4. You publish the video (for example, on Instagram) and send the newsletter to your subscribers.

The newsletter and the video therefore contain the same content. Those who follow you on Instagram see the video. Those on your mailing list receive the text directly in their inbox. I describe how to structure a single email, including links and a P.S., in the article Build an Email List.

Every Email Offers a Next Step

Under each newsletter, include a sentence like: “If you’re interested in taking the next step with me, do this and that.”

The next step depends on your business. It could be your webinar, a consultation with you, a product, or a visit to your store. The key is to include it under every email. The content is delivered daily. The next step is always available. Those who are ready will take it.

A Cycle of Video, Contact, and Email

Your video runs daily on Instagram, generating new contacts. They sign up and receive your email every day. Eventually, they’ll purchase something from you. This is a cycle that continues with each video. It’s a very simple process.

The challenge is that most people don’t do it. Many don’t even realize how simple it is. And those who do know often struggle to stay consistent. Creating something every day or every week requires discipline.

AI can handle a lot of these tasks for you today. It can write and send the newsletter, publish the video, reach out to new contacts, and even come up with an idea for your next video in the morning. Those who don’t want to use AI will have to do these steps manually. The most important thing is to keep moving forward.

Your First Step

Check what happens after someone leaves a comment on your video today:

  • Does everyone who comments automatically receive a private message? If not, set that up.
  • Does the message ask for their email address, or does it just send a link? Implement that question.
  • Is the second email, scheduled for tomorrow morning, ready? Write it with a single question that includes a timeframe, such as “this month.”
  • How often do you write to your subscribers? Establish a rhythm: daily, every other day, or once a week. A video can generate a newsletter.
  • Does each email include a next step? Write exactly one below it.

Frequently asked questions

How do I build an email newsletter?
First, you need subscribers, then a consistent schedule. I'm acquiring subscribers by offering a free book. Anyone who comments on my video will receive a private message where they can enter their email address. After that, I should ideally write daily. Each short video will become a newsletter; the AI will convert the transcript into text. I'll add a call to action to every email. If you can't manage daily posts, try posting every two days or once a week.
How does direct messaging work on Instagram?
A DM is a private direct message that only the recipient can see. I use them to connect with people who leave comments. Anyone who comments on my video with a single word will receive a public reply: “I just sent you a private message.” In the DM, I'll then provide a link to my free book. Or, I'll directly ask for the email address to which I should send the book.
How can I set up automated responses to comments on Instagram?
Using a tool like ManyChat or creating your own automation system is essential. Manually contacting 60 people every day is simply too much work. The automation system responds to every comment publicly and then sends a private message. This message either contains a link to your offer, or it first asks for the recipient's email address. In my case, the address is then automatically added to my customer database. I built that connection myself.
Are there any tricks to get more followers on Instagram?
You don't need any complicated tricks. What works is a short video each day, focused on your topic. Most people fail because they lack the discipline. However, gaining followers isn't my primary goal. I'm more interested in how many of them subscribe to my newsletter. That's why every video ends with an invitation: comment with a single word, and I'll send you my book. This way, a follower becomes a contact that I can reach out to again.
How do I write a newsletter effectively?
Write it from your own content. I take a short daily video, have it transcribed using AI, and then turn the transcript into the newsletter text. This way, you don't have to do double the work. Under each newsletter, I add a sentence like: “If you're interested in taking the next step with me, then do this and that.” Remain calm and gentle. You want to connect with your readers where they are, and not overwhelm them.
What creative email ideas are there?
A simple idea is a single question with a time reference, asked the morning after someone makes an entry. For example, “You requested a book yesterday. Are you planning to invest in stocks this month?” You can adapt the question to your topic, such as “Would you like to write a book this month?” or “Are you currently experiencing any dental issues?” Phrase it more gently than these rather pointed examples. When someone responds, it means they are serious. It allows you to directly engage in a conversation with them.

Free newsletter

Get the next article by email